Derrek Lee, Tommy Hanson, or Matt Wieters - 5th Keeper

[BALCO All-Stars]

14 team, 5x5 roto. Keep 5 each year. Currently am keeping Pedroia, Reyes, Holliday, and Bay. I've been just assuming that I'd freeze D Lee, but Hanson was a stud last year and is 10 years younger while D Lee is just an okay option at a very deep position...thoughts?

Options for final spot: Hanson, D Lee, Wieters

[BALCO All-Stars]

Bump

[Pogotheostrich]

What do you think your chances are next year? D. Lee is the best bet for 2010 but I'd probably keep Wieters.

[repperson29]

I would keep Wieters definately, he has the best long term potential out of those three (not totally sold on Hanson yet)

[goose56]

1. Wieters
2. Hanson
3. D Lee

[BALCO All-Stars]

What do you think your chances are next year? D. Lee is the best bet for 2010 but I'd probably keep Wieters.

I feel I can compete every year but I also like to build for the future. so it sounds like everyone is saying wieters...anyone else?

[HOOTIE]

Call me crazy, but i keep Weiters and Hanson, and drop Bay.

[theholdout12]

Id rank your keepers choices like this

Holliday
Reyes
Pedroia
Hanson
Bay
Wieters
Lee

[BALCO All-Stars]

Call me crazy, but i keep Weiters and Hanson, and drop Bay.

In a perfect world I will be able to trade bay for a solid 3B. But I don't know about straight up dropping him. Shouldn't he go .275/25/100/100/10 at least? And its not like he's old. But I also would like to fill OF last since its a much easier position to fill.

Anyone else?

[Pogotheostrich]

Shouldn't he go .275/25/100/100/10 at least?

I think that is pretty reasonable. I'd figure on more than 100 RBI with that lineup with a slightly worse BA and a slightly better HR total.