Keep 12! 4th year of league*WHIR*

[Konfusious]

I am in a 10 team roto league, the stats are the basics with the addition of whip, era and obp. We are keeping ten players and have the option of keeping 2 more who will cost us a pick based on their ADP. So if they are drafted in the top 100, then the player will cost me a 11th round and the 12th round pick. This league is also real salary league where players cost their real-life salary. The cap is $120 million.

Here are the players and next to them is their salary, please choose 12:
C= Victor Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
2B = Brian Roberts (10)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = BJ Upton (2)
OF = Carlos Lee (18.5)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Josh Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Nathan (11.25)
RP = Soria (3)

Thanks in advance. Please post your links.

[DaShiz23]

I am in a 10 team roto league, the stats are the basics with the addition of whip, era and obp. We are keeping ten players and have the option of keeping 2 more who will cost us a pick based on their ADP. So if they are drafted in the top 100, then the player will cost me a 11th round and the 12th round pick. This league is also real salary league where players cost their real-life salary. The cap is $120 million.

Here are the players and next to them is their salary, please choose 12:
C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
2B = Roberts (10)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Lee (18.5)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Nathan (11.25)
RP = Soria (3)

Thanks in advance. Please post your links.

[The Artful Dodger]

C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Soria (3)

[MaudDib]

C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Soria (3)

This looks pretty good. The only thing I would think about changing would be to take Roberts over Dunn. I have to believer that there will be a good 1B available in the draft where as most 2B will be gone.

[ensanimal]

C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
RP = Soria (3)

I'd rather keep Dunn over Roberts because of the way the rest of the keepers are set. This roster needs the power from Dunn a lot more than the speed of Roberts.

[DaveClay12]

C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
RP = Soria (3)

I'd rather keep Dunn over Roberts because of the way the rest of the keepers are set. This roster needs the power from Dunn a lot more than the speed of Roberts.

I agree with both the list, and the reasoning behind Dunn over Roberts. And I think Bucholtz over Coghlin. Much higher upside.

Good luck, and thanks for the help with mine!

[chargerss24]

Here are the players and next to them is their salary, please choose 12:
C= Victor Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
2B = Brian Roberts (10)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = BJ Upton (2)
OF = Carlos Lee (18.5)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Josh Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Nathan (11.25)
RP = Soria (3)

Thanks in advance. Please post your links.

Thanks for the help on mine!

[jeffmerk]

I am in a 10 team roto league, the stats are the basics with the addition of whip, era and obp. We are keeping ten players and have the option of keeping 2 more who will cost us a pick based on their ADP. So if they are drafted in the top 100, then the player will cost me a 11th round and the 12th round pick. This league is also real salary league where players cost their real-life salary. The cap is $120 million.

Here are the players and next to them is their salary, please choose 12:
C= Victor Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
2B = Brian Roberts (10)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = BJ Upton (2)
OF = Carlos Lee (18.5)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Josh Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)
RP = Nathan (11.25)
RP = Soria (3)

Thanks in advance. Please post your links.

[HOOTIE]

C= Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
RP = Soria (3)

[zippytrash]

Here's who I'd keep if I were you....

C= Victor Martinez (7)
1B= Dunn (12)
3B = Beckham (1)
SS = Tulowitzki (3.5)
OF = BJ Upton (2)
OF = Cruz (2)
OF = Ellsbury (3)
OF = Coghlan (1)
SP = Josh Johnson (4)
SP = Halladay (15.75)
SP = Nolasco (4)
SP = Buchholz (1)


Take a look at mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=398900