Who To Keep? WHIR

[NMax13]

10 team H2H

Keep 4

Pitcher Favored league...
Points as follows

Hitter Scoring
Hits (H) 1pt
Triples (3B) 1pt
Home Runs (HR) 2pts
Total Bases (TB) 1pt
Walks (BB) 1pt
Runs Scored (R) 1pt
Runs Batted In (RBI) 1pt
Stolen Bases (SB) 1pt
Strikeouts (K) -1pt
Hitting for the Cycle (CYC) 15pt

Pitcher Scoring
Innings Pitched (IP) 3pts
Hits Allowed (H) -1pt
Earned Runs (ER) -2pts
Strikeouts (K) 2pts
Wins (W) 8pts
Losses (L) -5pts
Saves (SV) 5pts
Blown Saves (BS) -2pts
Quality Starts (QS) 2pts
No Hitters (NH) 25pts

Starting Line Up is 1 C, 5 Infielders (1B 2B SS 3B IF), 4 outfielders, 2 Utility, 3 P, 4 SP, 1 RP

My Team is as follows

C Yadier Molina
1B Ryan Howard
2B Dan Uggla
3B Evan Longoria
SS Derek Jeter
IF Chone Figgins
OF Torii Hunter
OF Cody Ross
OF Hunter Pence
OF Nick Swisher
UTIL Adam Jones
UTIL Luke Scott
Bench Hank Blalock
Bench Mike Lowell

P Matt Garza
P Jarrod Washburn
P Andrew Bailey
SP Dan Haren
SP Chad Billingsley
SP Josh Johnson
SP Carl Pavano
RP Heath Bell
Bench Scott Kazmir
Bench Francisco Liriano, Min SP

I have 1st Overall Draft pick this year.

As i mentioned, I get to keep 4. Now I have a good situation here... I have 2 solid pitchers in Haren and Johnson, and I really think Bills is going to bounce back. i also like having Howard and Longo... however, I only get 4...

Here is my thought process on this... with pick #1... I keep Longo, Howard, Bills, and Johnson/Haren and pick up Johnson or Haren with the #1 pick... which will assure me a soild pitcher to start off in 2011...

Or, I keep my three pitchers, and drop Longo or Howard and see what's available at #1.

Is there somethign even better I havent considered???

What do you guys think? I definitely have a good sitaution here... but what will work out best for me????

Thanks for your help!

[uk_bosox]

Firstly you are in a great position! Personally I'd keep 2 bats and 2 Pitchers probably

Evan Longoria
Ryan Howard
Chad Billingsley
Dan Haren

See what the FA pool is like and you can always pick Josh Johnson up again!

[ayebatter]

Howard
Longoria
Haren
Pence/Jones/Johnson any of the 3 work depending on what your league values more hitting/pitching.

[plapre3]

Howard
Longoria
Haren
JOHNSON

Josh Joshnson is a beast; a top 15 SP next season. Billingsley has way too many question marks to warrant keeping and is simply not in the same class as Johnson.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=398796

[pacotaco27]

Howard, Longoria, Haren, then probably Johnson but I'd also consider Billingsley or Jeter.

[chinch sacs]

Howard
Longoria
Haren
JOHNSON

Josh Joshnson is a beast; a top 15 SP next season. Billingsley has way too many question marks to warrant keeping and is simply not in the same class as Johnson.

I hear that! I like Billingsley as much as the next guy, but gotta go Johnson here.

Me? http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=398819

[NMax13]

Ok well you guys seem to think keeping both bats and dropping one picther, probably Bills, is the best way to go with this...

I think i may just do that and see who is available at my first pick.

Thanks for your help!