STOP SHOUTING. I STILL HAVE A HANGOVER.
In this case, I lean toward McLouth. Both guys are 28, so even though they recently broke out, neither is really a prospect. If you are using them almost strictly at Util, then you really just want bigger numbers, and McLouth does that across the board. Ramirez also qualifies at SS and OF in some leagues, but an IF is just less valuable if you use them at Util, where you could just as easily plug in a CI or OF. And Jeter played 155 games last year.
Insanity: Doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results - Albert Einstein