Keeper Question

[jeffmerk]

5x5 H2H league. I can keep 6.

Which 6 should I keep

Mauer
Kinsler
Braun
Kemp
Sizemore
BJ Upton
G Beckham
Ichiro
J Werth
Cliff Lee
Wainwright
Hamels

Thanks!

Please help with my posts:

viewtopic.php?t=398540&start=10

ditto

[NY Knights]

Mauer
Braun
Kinsler
Kemp
Sizemore
Wainwright

The Cliff Lee/Wainwright decision is close, and they should be drafted within a round of each other. Lee goes to a good pitcher's ballpark, but for me the nod goes to the 28 year old in the NL.

[HOOTIE]

Mauer
Kinsler
Braun
Kemp
Sizemore
Upton

[upstate32]

Definite keepers - Mauer, Kinsler, Sizemore, Kemp and Braun.

After that I think I would go with Lee. Not loving this selection but I don't really think you can keep anyone over him. Wainwright is nice and all but Lee is better. Beckham is tempting but I don't see how you can keep him over Lee. Werth is alright but again no way you can keep him over any of the other guys plus that would give your 4 OF and no need to do that. Also you have a better chance that Wainwright will still be there at the 3rd pick than Lee still being there.

By the way, how many teams are in this league. That might change who to keep but it might not either.

10 team league.

I love Beckham, but not more than any of the other offensive guys. Plus with the majority of teams already keeping a SS....I'm hoping to re-draft him too!!

One guy in the league has awful offensive guys, but has Lincecum, Haren, and King Felix. I'm thinking about offering BJ Upton or Werth and Lee or Wainwright for one of those two....hence making my 6th keeper an easy decision.