First time keeper league owner in need of some help.

[Curtis Pride]

Yeah, don't keep Johan. Definitely DO NOT. He's in decline, and looks to be a serious risk to injury.

Greinke is obvious.

The size of the league and positions can have an impact. If it were a deeper league, I'd say keep Hill, but with a 10 team league, finding a 2b shouldn't be too hard, and with OPS as a category, it makes Votto or Lind even more valuable.

Votto or Lind are your best options for a 4th keeper.

I like Votto a little more than Lind given that he's got more of a track record and has SB upside, but you already have Miguel Cabrera, so an argument can be made for keeping Lind instead.

I'd honestly probably keep Lind.