Wright, Kinsler or Tulo?...WHIR

[The Artful Dodger]

Take Wright/Shields then don't bother keeping Beckham in my opinion and hold onto Andrus.

Why not? Beckham can have a 20/10 season within reason from a scarcer position at just 24. Those keepers are pretty much spot-on.

As far as Wright/Tulo peaking, well, let me put it this way. Aside from the disappointing HR total, Wright was a relatively safe bet across the board. Contrast this to Tulowitzki who had an '07 remembered for having wrapped up strongly, an '08 thrown off by injury, and an '09 where Tulo had another breakthrough, but he just happened to trade line drives for HR too. At the moment, I'd say Wright is safer than Tulowitzki and so, of the three between those two and Kinsler, he'd be the pick here.

[PeteDog13]

These potential deals have since evolved to this....

Kinsler and Jay Bruce for Wright and Sizemore

or

Kinsler and Peavy for Tulo and Josh Johnson.

Not sure I want to deal Bruce, but interested in your thoughts.

[kidsilk]

I would take the Wright and Sizemore side any day. They both are too good not to bounce back from disappointing seasons. Artful Dodger was right on about Wright and I would much rather have Sizemore than Bruce.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=398621