Rank: Beckett, Peavy, Grienke, Webb, Hamels, Haren...WHIR!

[Prooks25]

Rank these SPs in a 5x5 roto standard stats league...

Beckett, Peavy, Grienke, Webb, Hamels, Haren...

I have some bounce back guys here, injury guys, come back down to earth guys, possible fluke guys...so I wanna see what you people are thinking.

[mprice25]

Beckett, peavy, hamels, haren, grienke, webb

Haren - Safest, most consistent
Peavy - Huge bounceback year. Wasn't really trying in SD. Only question mark is the switch to AL
Grienke - 3.4 ERA, 190k's, 13-9
Hamels
Webb
Beckett - I've lost all faith in Beckett

[HOOTIE]

Greinke
Haren
Peavy
Hamels
Webb
Beckett

[ensanimal]

Greinke
Haren
Peavy
Hamels
Webb
Beckett

This.

[misterf]

Greinke and Haren are #1 and #1A. They are your elite and a clear notch above the other guys. They are both fantasy "Aces."

Your 2nd tier guys are Beckett and Peavy. I know Peavy is coming off an injury, but I actually like Peavy slightly more than Beckett.

Hamels and Webb are both another step down, but still solid SP's. But I trust Webb a lot more than I trust Hamels. Webb was hurt, Hamels just stank last year.

So, here is my ranking:

Greinke (fantasy ace)
Haren (fantasy ace)
Peavy (#2 fantasy sp)
Beckett (#2 fantasy sp)
Webb (#3 fantasy sp...with at least #2 upside)
Hamels (#3 fantasy sp)


Help with mine?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=398345

[KDOGG]

Greinke and Haren are #1 and #1A. They are your elite and a clear notch above the other guys. They are both fantasy "Aces."

Your 2nd tier guys are Beckett and Peavy. I know Peavy is coming off an injury, but I actually like Peavy slightly more than Beckett.

Hamels and Webb are both another step down, but still solid SP's. But I trust Webb a lot more than I trust Hamels. Webb was hurt, Hamels just stank last year.

So, here is my ranking:

Greinke (fantasy ace)
Haren (fantasy ace)
Peavy (#2 fantasy sp)
Beckett (#2 fantasy sp)
Webb (#3 fantasy sp...with at least #2 upside)
Hamels (#3 fantasy sp)


Help with mine?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=398345

i agree with this ranking the most except I would move Beckett ahead of Peavy.

[kidsilk]

Greinke
Haren
Peavy
Hamels
Webb
Beckett

I also agree with this.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=398378

[The Artful Dodger]

Greinke
Haren

Hamels
Peavy

Beckett
Webb

Greinke and Haren are easily the head of the class in that order. I'm still a believer in Hamels next year whereas I can see Peavy having a negative correction to his ERA in a full season in the AL (especially at the Cell), but the strikeouts should be there. Webb is a wild card for me at this point and it all depends on how he fares this Spring, which justifies the bottom of the barrel.