Sandoval and Wilson for Ellsbury and Melky?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

12 team dynasty league where we each took over the rosters of a National League Team and an American League Team and made cuts, etc. 5x5 roto style. Very active league with lots of trading and transactions.

I have been offered Jacoby Ellsbury and Melky Cabrera for my Pablo Sandoval and Brian Wilson. This would leave me a closer short but I would still have Nathan. Sandoval should break out and have a huge year but so should Ellsbury and I need his speed. I might want a SP in return if I do this deal instead of Melky. What do you guys think and should I ask for more or just stay put?

My Team:

C-Posada
1B-Morneau
2B-Utley
SS-Theriot
3B-Sandoval
CI-Ramirez
MI-Uggla
OF-Cuddyer
OF-Kubel
OF-Soriano
UTI-Reynolds
BN-Cantu

Rotation:
SP-Lincecum
SP-Lilly
SP-Slowey
SP-Baker
SP-Blackburn
BN-Sanchez
BN-Liriano
BN-
BN-Lannan
BN-Duensing
BN-Bonser
BN-Sandowski

Bullpen

Wilson
Nathan
Affeldt
Mijares
Rauch
Neshek
BN-Romo
BN-Valdez


His Team:

C Miguel Montero
1B Adrian Gonzalez
2B Dustin Pedroia
3B Kevin Youklis
SSJason Bartlett
LF Shin Soo Choo
CF Jacoby Ellsbury
RF Nolan Riemold
DH
CIMark Teahen
MI
OH Melky Cabrera

SP Clay Buckholz
SP Josh Beckett
SP Jon Lestor
SP Jonny Cueto
SP

RP Phil Hughes
RP Ryan Perry
RP Luke Gregerson
RP Edward Mujica
clP Jonathon Papelbon
clP Francisco Cordero

[kidsilk]

He said that if I don't want Melky I can chose between Hermida and Reimold. Any opinions out there?

[ensanimal]

I'd do it. You can slide Reynolds into the 3b spot, so you won't hurt there. You do need another top OF, and Ellsbury gives the sb's you also need.

I would also rather have Reimold over Cabrera.

I'm sure you can find saves in a 12 team league during the season if not in the off season.

[BoBtheMule]

def. agree w/ the last poster

[MotorCityKitties]

Do it and take Reimold.

[B-Chad]

I would NOT have done it with Melky, I would do it with Reimold. I think Reimold has a sneaky good skill set. He draws a healthy number of walks, has good pop, and was surprisingly eficient on the base paths. Ellsbury and Reimold should really help your SB totals and fill out your OF.