OK, you pick 8 keepers

[NY Knights]

Just to get some closure here, this morning I completed a 3 team trade (!!), where I sent away Markakis, Adam Jones, and Hanson to get back Mark Reynolds and Mat Gamel. We are allowed to keep a 9th player rookie (and take him with our 26th and final draft pick), as long as he meets the standards for a rookie (130 or less AB, or 50 or less IP), and Gamel does. That might sound like a lot for me to give up, but 3B has been a hole for me for the last 2 years, I got the best player in my deal, and I definitely had the spare OFs to give. Reynolds is projecting as a 2nd round pick, Markakis about 5th, Adam Jones around 7th, and Hanson 8th or 9th.

So, as it stands, my keepers now look like

Pujols
Votto
Pedroia
Rollins
Reynolds
Crawford
Hamilton
Peavy
Gamel (or Matusz) as rookie 9th keeper
with McCutchen in case of emergencies

Thanks for the input guys.