2B Rankings for 2010

[Trainer of Dolphins]

How do the top 10 or so 2 baggers rank next year?

[Trainer of Dolphins]

1-Utley
2-Kinser
3-Pedroia
4-Cano
5-B. Phillips
6-B. Roberts
7-A. Hill
8-Uggla
9-Weeks
10-Zobrist

[fast dogs]

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Pedroia
5 Cano
5.5 Beckham
6 Phillips
7 Roberts
8 Zobrist
9 Lopez
10 McGehee
EDIT: probably a good call on Beckham in these list,tho its certainly not impossible the Sox change their mind again between now & opening day. Or see him & Alexei swap and be SS elig 2 weeks into the season. If its a keeper I move him up another spot
Wasn't too long ago, 2nd base was such a weak & shallow position; now look at it!

[BillyHallDisciple]

I don't think Rickie Weeks belongs on any Top 10 lists for 2B's. He's got talent, but man, talk about fragile:

Source: http://www2.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/p ... kie_Weeks/

Jun 14, 2009: Transferred from the 15-day DL to the 60-day DL (wrist injury).
May 19, 2009: Wrist injury, 15-day DL.
May 18, 2009: Wrist injury, remainder of the regular season.
Feb 3, 2009: Re-signed by the Milwaukee Brewers to a one-year contract.
Aug 20, 2008: Missed 2 games (left thumb injury).
Aug 18, 2008: Left thumb injury, day-to-day.
Jul 2, 2008: Missed 1 game (stomach virus).
Jul 1, 2008: Stomach virus, day-to-day.
Jun 22, 2008: Missed 12 games (sore left knee).
Jun 9, 2008: Sore left knee, 15-day DL (retroactive to June 7th).
Jun 8, 2008: Sore left knee, day-to-day.
Mar 2, 2008: Re-signed by the Milwaukee Brewers to a one-year contract.
Aug 10, 2007: Recalled from Nashville (AAA).
Aug 1, 2007: Optioned to Nashville (AAA).
Jun 18, 2007: Missed 17 games (wrist injury).
May 31, 2007: Wrist injury, 15-day DL.
May 21, 2007: Missed 4 games (wrist injury).
May 17, 2007: Wrist injury, day-to-day.
May 1, 2007: Missed 2 games (right index finger).
Apr 30, 2007: Right index finger, day-to-day.
Oct 2, 2006: Missed the last 62 games of the regular season (wrist injury).
Sep 1, 2006: Transferred from the 15-day DL to the 60-day DL (wrist injury).
Jul 29, 2006: Wrist injury, 15-day DL.
Jul 25, 2006: Wrist injury, day-to-day.

[BillyHallDisciple]

Here's my Top 10. Pretty much in agreement with everyone else's except I'm a little higher on Zobrist than some others on the board:

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Cano
5 Pedroia
6 Zobrist
7 Phillips
8 Roberts
9 Uggla
10 J Lopez

[Frenchiegangsta9]

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Phillips
5 Roberts
6 Pedroia
7 Cano
8 Zobrist
9 Lopez
10 McGehee

gotta go against traffic on this one.

[GiantsFan14]

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Phillips
5 Roberts
6 Pedroia
7 Cano
8 Zobrist
9 Lopez
10 McGehee

gotta go against traffic on this one.

at a quick glance and without doing any actual research, i like this list.

[kab21]

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Phillips
5 Roberts
6 Pedroia
7 Cano
8 Zobrist
9 Lopez
10 McGehee

gotta go against traffic on this one.

at a quick glance and without doing any actual research, i like this list.

I have to crunch some numbers but it's pretty good with two exceptions. I like Phillips less and less every year. And McGehee isn't this good since his MiLB numbers don't match his half season last year. I'll take Uggla's power even with the mediocre avg.

[Havok1517]

Really? Gordon Beckham is the starting 2B for the White Sox in 2010 and he'll be Top 10 at least.

White Sox GM Kenny Williams said Friday that Gordon Beckham will serve as the club's starting second baseman in 2010.
Chris Getz and Josh Fields were shipped to the Royals on Friday for Mark Teahen, who will take over at third base in Chicago. "I can't seem to find the position I've played my whole career," Beckham, a natural shortstop, told MLB.com. He started over 100 games at third base in '09, but this is the most logical way for the White Sox to fit Teahen into the lineup.
Source: WhiteSox.mlb.com

[GiantsFan14]

1 Utley
2 Kinsler
3 Hill
4 Phillips
5 Roberts
6 Pedroia
7 Cano
8 Zobrist
9 Lopez
10 McGehee

gotta go against traffic on this one.

at a quick glance and without doing any actual research, i like this list.

I have to crunch some numbers but it's pretty good with two exceptions. I like Phillips less and less every year. And McGehee isn't this good since his MiLB numbers don't match his half season last year. I'll take Uggla's power even with the mediocre avg.

ya i was more of commenting on the top 9, shoulda said that, would def take uggla over mcgehee.