2010 Top 50 Prospects UPDATED 1/26

[oddmanout7]

I posted an update to my top 50 and welcome all comments.

[kab21]

I don't think FMart has been discussed enough. I don't like his ranking. He's been hurt almost every year in the minors (injury-prone). His plate discipline is so-so. If you dismiss his one spectacular month last year you have to go back to 2006 to find a decent season. He doesn't steal bases. he has a very high GB rate (making it difficult to hit a lot HR's). Do you know who he reminds me of? Delmon Young.

[MasterX1918]

I'm not sure if Ethan Martin belongs in top 50 over some other guys, like hudson montgomery stewart etc...

[jeffmerk]

However, I do believe that 90% of all expert lists will have Strasburg first. If you don't have him first, you better be prepared to explain yourself.

I would take that bet in a heartbeat. Heyward is the top prospect and nobody needs to justify ranking him their, especially when the context is fantasy baseball. I don't know who you consider "experts" but well over 10% of them will have Heyward #1.

Keith Law and Jonathan Mayo came out with their lists today and both have Heyward #1.

[oddmanout7]

Keith Law and Jonathan Mayo came out with their lists today and both have Heyward #1.

Thanks for the news. I posted both of their top 50 lists in the 1st post of this thread.

[Steve-o]

However, I do believe that 90% of all expert lists will have Strasburg first. If you don't have him first, you better be prepared to explain yourself.

I would take that bet in a heartbeat. Heyward is the top prospect and nobody needs to justify ranking him their, especially when the context is fantasy baseball. I don't know who you consider "experts" but well over 10% of them will have Heyward #1.

Keith Law and Jonathan Mayo came out with their lists today and both have Heyward #1.

I swear I logged on today just to eat crow by pointing this out. I admit I was very wrong.