Johnny Tuttle wrote:Am I right in thinking here the question has been boiled down to Markakis v. Wainwright?
that's what the question is for me
raiders_umpire wrote:Pretty easy choice for me. Markakis is still only 25 years old, and has proven to be a 300 hitter with lots of doubles. I would take the chance that one day those doubles start turning into a few more homers at his age.
and here's the answer, not as easy a choice for me but I'll usually lean toward the hitter over the pitcher and the main reason is how fragile pitchers are, heck they get hurt playing guitar hero.