With this few keepers, I almost feel reckless, but for the next three, I'd want Weiters, Reyes, and Hanson. Are these guaranteed to be the best values there? No. But they have the most chance to be special for you, and that counts for me.
The other guys are just pedestrian enough that I'd risk it. Votto's production isn't that great from 1B. The other Upton's all over the place. Billingsley ended the year on such a down note I fear injury. Broxton's not necessarily in the picture. Cruz isn't a top 60 player for me.
Most of the time, with this small keeper set (only 60 for the league), I'd say take the best production for next year and next year alone. Here, I'm reversing that on the assumption that you can recoup decent players in the draft easily. You can't grab elite that easily, and the three I like here could easily be elite.