Pick 5 Keepers

[dbreer23]

Ryan Braun
Chase Utley
Tim Lincecum
Matt Kemp
Jose Reyes

I would keep Reyes over Longoria. Reyes will be a freak if he recovers fully from surgery and I think Longoria is somewhat overrated.

Gotta disagree with this one, if only for the options available otherwise...I'd rather have Zobrist at SS than Figgins at 3B - keep Reyes and lose Longo, and the pickings at 3B are really slim; SS looks slightly more promising.

[prguy1979]

Last two for me would be Kemp and Longoria....Reyes is hard to throw back but he is to ify as is the entiere Mets organization

[callacim]

ok well if you look at this kids keepers, he plays with a bunch of idiots as he has all 1st rounders basically...so exactly what i already said, he can easily take the chance on keeping reyes, especially since hes a SS and thats worst position by far to fill, as after hanley tulo and reyes mayyyybe rollins, there is no one.....this kid should win the league regardless

[MrAccoe]

ok well if you look at this kids keepers, he plays with a bunch of idiots as he has all 1st rounders basically...so exactly what i already said, he can easily take the chance on keeping reyes, especially since hes a SS and thats worst position by far to fill, as after hanley tulo and reyes mayyyybe rollins, there is no one.....this kid should win the league regardless

Well he did mention that this is going to be his 4th year in this league. This was Kemp's 3rd full year, Longoria's 2nd and Braun's 3rd also... so I wouldn't be so quick to say that he plays with idiots.

In any case, 3rd base isn't as deep as it used to be, so I'd keep Longoria as your 5th.

[theeminence]

ok well if you look at this kids keepers, he plays with a bunch of idiots as he has all 1st rounders basically...so exactly what i already said, he can easily take the chance on keeping reyes, especially since hes a SS and thats worst position by far to fill, as after hanley tulo and reyes mayyyybe rollins, there is no one.....this kid should win the league regardless

Well, its not like I drafted them all last year, I got all of them before they were proven in the majors with the exception of Utley and Reyes in the 1st year, and I didn't win the past year since its a H2H league after all.

Anyways I think I'm going to end up keeping Longoria, since my team has been mediocre power-wise due to some poor 1B play (started a mix of Cantu, Helton and Butler most of the year), factored in with Reyes and his injury.