Pick 5 keepers... WHIR

[Spectrum]

H2H points league. Keepers use your first 5 picks for next year, so not a big point in keeping value. My picks are in bold. Should I just keep 5 hitters and no pitchers (2 of Hamilton/Rollins/Roberts). Hate points leagues, and feel like there are always solid starters in the draft and FA during the season.

C- Russell Martin
1B- Derek Lee
2B- Brian Roberts
SS- Jimmy Rollins
3B- Evan Longoria
OF- Matt Kemp
OF- Andre Ethier
OF- Jay Bruce
OF- Chris Young
OF- Josh Hamilton
DL- Grady Sizemore

SP- Chris Carpenter
SP- Clayton Kershaw
SP- Tommy Hanson
SP- Jair Jurrjens
SP- Javier Vazquez
SP- Scott Kazmir
SP- Clay Bucholz
SP- Wade Davis
SP- Max Scherzer
RP- David Aardsma
RP- Kerry Wood

[kmoneybags]

I would go:

Rollins
Longoria
Kemp
Hamilton
Sizemore

If you really wanted to keep Carp then I'd choose him over Rollins. I just think with Rollins, Kemp, and Sizemore you have a great power-speed combo to go along with Longoria and Hamilton (assuming he can get back on track).

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=397562

[luckygehrig]

I think I'd keep Rollins, Longoria, Kemp, Sizemore, and Carpenter. You'll have a nice base for your offense with that as well as an ace. I think you can fill in the rest of the rotation pretty well through the draft.

[raiders_umpire]

SS- Jimmy Rollins
3B- Evan Longoria
OF- Matt Kemp
OF- Josh Hamilton
DL- Grady Sizemore

[The Artful Dodger]

SS- Jimmy Rollins
3B- Evan Longoria
OF- Matt Kemp
OF- Josh Hamilton
DL- Grady Sizemore

I think that's your best 5. Not a fan of keeping Carpenter and while Vazquez is your best keeper ace, I'd go with the best five hitters next year.

[prguy1979]

I truly expect Hamilton to have a monster season next year just thats a bold prediction i know....my keepers would be Carpenter, Roberts, Rollins, Hamilton and Longoria...however.....no one can blame you for keeping Kemp over Hamilton or Carpenter....if you are allowed to trade during the off season i would try to give up a few of the guys that your not keeping plus any of these guys, maybe even two, for a top 5 guy like Pujols, A-Rod, Ramirez, Howard or Lincecum...can you reply to my post?

viewtopic.php?t=397698