Is Adam Wainwright a keeper?

[joepig]

In a 12 team league, we can keep 3 players, at least 1 batter and 1 pitcher.
Here are the "keeper-worthy" players in my book.

Joe Mauer
Justin Morneau
David Wright
Carlos Lee
Nick Markakis
Justin Upton
Dan Haren
Adam Wainwright

Who would you keep from this list? WHIR

[RedSoxNation04]

If you have to keep one pitcher from that group, I probably keep Haren over Wainwright. Wainwright is having a nice season, but Haren would be my choice.

[joepig]

so you'd keep 2 batters and Haren and not 1 batter + Haren and Wainwright?

[Padres Fan]

My keepers would be Mauer/Wright/Haren, I like Wainwright but he still hasn't proved as much as haren has as a big time winner, (if only Arizona could play better) and Haren Strikes out more, but it's close.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=397092

[RedSoxNation04]

so you'd keep 2 batters and Haren and not 1 batter + Haren and Wainwright?

Yes. I would keep Mauer, Upton and Haren.