Which 1 Would You Keep: Wainwright or Soriano?

[zebulon]

Claimed Soriano off waivers the other day without realizing that he was most likely going to miss the rest of the season. However, I am trying to figure out if I should consider keeping him. I'm going to assume that if he goes through with surgery this month that he should recover in plenty of time and hopefully be at 100% by Spring Training. So, I'd be banking on him rebounding to his previous form.

My current expected keepers are: (We keep 4 + 1 rookie)

Miguel Cabrera
Matt Kemp
Carlos Beltran
--
Nolan Reimold (rookie)

My best options for the 4th slot are:
Soriano
Wainwright
Kershaw
Aaron Hill
Bartlett

[bazzy_51]

of those i would go with Wainwright over Soriano simply because your already keeping 2 OF as is. Wainwright would give you that one ace to build your staff around in the draft next year. Nice set of keepers!

[gocards]

I would go with Wainright as well.

[raiders_umpire]

Kershaw has ace ability. I would keep Kershaw, even though Wainwright has been mighty good this year.