Please help my WIFE pick her 5 keepers..she doesnt trust me!

[Broncos246]

If she retains the option to keep less than 5, I would probably keep less. For a 10 team league, I would assume that this is a team near the bottom of the league.

If I HAD to keep 5 I would keep:

Wieters, The Baconator (Miggy), Wright, Hamels, Jay Bruce

However, I would drop Jay Bruce if I could keep less than 5 because I don't see him as much more than a platoon player for the next year or so. Can't argue with his power though...

[raiders_umpire]

1B - Miguel Cabrera
3B - David Wright
OF- Jay Bruce
Cole Hamels
Jonathan Papelbon


Since it is a 10 team league, I would let Wieters go and keep the stud closer.

[wkpdpack]

With only keeping 5 players, I don't think you can keep a closer. It would be hard for me to keep a pitcher as well, but I could argue keeping Hamels. I wouldn't risk keeping Peavy with his elbow issues right now. That said, I'd go with

MCab
Wieters
Wright
McCutcheon
Bruce or Hamels

Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=396996

[angels7777]

Wright
M-Cab
Peavy
Pappelbon
Hamels

I think guys like Bruce, McCutcheon, Wieters (who has proven nothing thus far) can easily be redrafted in a 10 teamer if she really wants them

viewtopic.php?t=396971