Quick Vote... Aramais or Reynolds in a 3 year keeper? WHIR

[TheBambino]

Hey guys... im thinking of moving either but will need to keep the other for next year and the year after.. which one should I keep and why?

Thanks a million...
leave a link

_________________________________________
10 Team 3 Year Keeper (Keep 6) Mixed 5x5 Roto League

C: Montero
1B: Morneau
2B: Utley
SS: Jeter
3B: A. Ramirez
OF: Sizemore, Bay, M Ramirez, Matsui
UTIL: Reynolds, Tulowitzki, Martin
SP: Haren, Billingsley, Lackey, Carpenter, J Johnson
RP: Nathan, Street, Howell, Nunez, Downs

[TheBambino]

bump... please help guys!

[Lips]

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=396542

I would take Reynolds. well balanced in hr, sb, runs and rbi. Strikes out a lot, but has kept his avg respectable. He's only 26, ramirez is 30. Aramis didn't play as much as Reynolds this year, but Aramis will only go down hill on this side of 30. The only stat that Ramirez is close to Reynolds this year is RBI (if you prorate it based on even amounts of at bats). 38 hr vs. 10 (prorated to 23 in 490 ab); 21 sb vs. 0; 81 runs vs. 27 (prorated to 64); 84 rbi vs 38 (prorated to 90). ramirez never stole more than 2 bases in a year. Reynolds is fully balanced, strong in every category except Batting Average, in which he isn't weak, he is still decent in avg. I think this is a no brainer.