Johan trade - my deadline is today - WHIR

[Diamond Miners]

I play in a H2H points league that starts 10 pitchers (SP or RP, doesn't matter which).

My current rotation is:
1. Lincecum (1 year left on his contract - goes back to draft next year)
2. Johan (3y)
3. Kershaw (4y)
4. Joba (3y)
5. FRod (2y)
6. Nathan (1y)
7. De La Rosa
8. Arroyo
9. J.Shields
10. Francisco

Bench: Cook (just hit the DL), R.Soriano, M.M.Adams

Would you trade Johan (3 years...2 after this season) for Wandy Rodriguez, Heath Bell, and Randy Wolf?

1. Does this improve my team this year?
2. Would 2 or 3 years (not sure which, depends on my other keepers) of Wandy be worth 2 years of Johan? I doubt I'd keep Bell, and Wolf is no way a keeper.

Thoughts and thanks for the quick feedback!

[bazzy_51]

then why would you trade Johan? unless your still in it somewhat, and even if you are i still think that kills your keeper potential for this year. if your out of it then there is NO WAY i do this deal cuz your essentially trading Johan for Wandy which is horrible. again if your out of it i would actually deal Lincecum for the top bidder seens how you can't keep him after this year anyways. but again if your out of it no way i deal Johan for that, even if you are i think its still way too close to do seens how you lose your #2 to gain Wandy who could potentially be your 5th/6th best pitcher behind Lincy, Kershaw, FRod, Nathan and potentially Joba to end the year... hope it helps a bit...

help me out...

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=396487&p=3149940#p3149940

[lyons595]

Agree wit the above.
Lincecum is the guy to move. For example, in my league im in 2nd place, and looking to the playoffs, Id gladly add Lince for the rest of the year and give you just about anyone you want.

DOnt let Johan go.

help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=396520

[Lips]

I wouldn't do it. The Mets shouldn't be this horrible next two years, Johan will be big stud for those two, He should still be solid this year. Wandy for three isn't equal to Johan for next year, let alone 2. Keeping Bell, makes it closer, but not worth it. Keep Johan, he's trying to sucker you. Wandy having great year but no evidence it isn't a flash in the pan. Johan having his worst year, because his team fell apart around him. The odds of Johan being fantastick two more years over Wandy's odds of repeating this years performance even once are like the odds of the yankees making the playoffs compared to the Nationals. Keep Johan.


Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=396542