M.Cabrera, Zimmerman, or A.Rod

[oncogene]

Miggy Cabrera or Ryan Zimmerman or A.Rod, how would you rank the 3 in a keeper league?


How close (or far apart) are the 3?

Stats are R,H,HR,RBI, SB, K, E, %

Thanks abunch

[oncogene]

Anyone?

Abit urgent... trade deadline this weekend

[woowoo crew]

tough one, but i'd go with:

miggy
arod
zimmerman

** the differential is minimal in my opinion. i think all are good keepers, but i'd keep miggy first.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=396116

[skmo2345]

tough one, but i'd go with:

miggy
arod
zimmerman

** the differential is minimal in my opinion. i think all are good keepers, but i'd keep miggy first.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=396116

Agreed.

[activechamp2006]

Miggy
Arod



Zimmerman

[High Inside Heater]

if your looking for a future 3B Miggy has now lost eligibility there and has bBeen a permanent 1B for Detroit for almost two years now. A-rod is also getting up in age and id much rather have the up and coming 3B in Zimmerman then Arod.

as far as hitting wise id go Miggy first of course but for a long term 3B? I'd Go Zimmerman without question since Miggy is now a 1B.