My Abreu, Ervin, Clay for Hamels and De la Rosa

[njknights]

20 players are kept
5v5 12 team league

C: Montero
1B : D.Lee
2B : Scutaro
3B : Chipper
SS : Hanley
LF : Braun
CF : McCutchen
RF : Abreu
UTIL : Ludwick
Bench : Huff, Stewart, Willingham
Minors : Bryce Harper, Desmond Jennings, Jose Tabata, Freddie Freeman, Chris Marrero, Matt LaPorta

SP : Jered Weaver, Brett Anderson, Clay Buchholz, Brian Bannister, Ricky Nolasco, Ervin Santana, Scott Richmond, Erik Bedard, Brad Bergesen, Chris Young
RP : Broxton, Street, Jenks, Hughes, Wilson
Minors : Chacin,

and the trade

My Abreu, Ervin, Clay and 1st round prospect
for
his Hamels and De La Rosa?

any ideas

WHIR

[oakscorps]

Sorry but the way Hamels is pitching this year I wouldnt do it

[sweettortilla]

What is your motive? Are you trying to win this year or upgrade your keepers? I think Hamels is the best keeper in the bunch, but I hate how much you're giving up - especially a 1st pick.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=396008

[njknights]

i was trying to clear an outfield spot and i had over 20 people worth keeping... and im like 14 games out of a playoff spot but if i win the next few weeks ill be knocking people in playoffs spot down so i could possibly squeeze in

[bazzy_51]

i think you MIGHT be able to get more value for abreu, hes been a sweet pick this season... but if thats all you can get you have to do that trade, your pitching staff is dismal at best...Weaver is a nice play, but not an ace and thats what your using him as, Weaver/Nolasco/Anderson as a 1/2/3 is kind of weak.. id do this deal simply because you have some OF depth and no pitching...

[sigriffey]

if you want to upgrade a keeper, you can get better than Hamels IMO. I would either give up less (Abreu should fetch more i think) or ask for more.