need help quick b4 offer is cancelled.......WHIR

[DaRawZz]

12team league H2H
R, HR, RBI, SB, BB, K, TB, AVG
W, L, SV. K, WHIP, ERA, QS


C---JOE MAUER__________SP---OSWALT
1B---BERKMAN__________SP---DANKS
1B---HELTON ____________ SP---WEAVER
2B---CANO _____________SP---HAPP
SS---EV. CABRERA__________SP---WOLF
3B---WRIGHT_____________SP---KURODA
SS---JETER _______________RP---JENKS
OF/1B---DUNN_____________RP---CAPPS
OF---DYE_________________RP---WILSON
OF---WELLS_______________SP---HOCHEVAR
OF---CHOO
OF--- QUENTIN
OF---GUTIERREZ


i give up dunn quentin and capps for manny and valverde

should i do it? am i giving up too much?

only reason im contemplating this is because i think dunn has hit his ceiling. leave links thanks

[bigken117]

Dunn and Quentin should outperform Manny + WW pickup

pass

[twistedude]

I'd pass as well. I think Dunn will outperform Manny, and Quentin/Capps has an edge on Valverde as well. Close, but no cigar.

Here's mine, thanks for your help: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=395843

[DaRawZz]

yea but im also getting valverde who is way better than capps. remember this is a H2H leaague
how bout if i counter with oswalt and quentin 4 manny and valverde?

[mj85]

I'd rather do the last deal you mentioned. If they want Quentin + Dunn, I would ask for another decent bat.

[sigriffey]

Counter with the Oswalt one ... could be nice for you.

[DaRawZz]

he wont do the oswalt one because he needs 2 bats he said. i tried offering choo quentin and oswalt 4 mannyvalverde and rajai davis but he declined. idk what to do but im trying 2 get manny while his value is low-any ideas anyone?

[dubstar]

Dunn may have hit a ceiling, but he is capable as staying at this high rate for the rest of the year. I would pass on this

[Lips]

I think it's equal, but I just don't like Dunn very much as he can't hit anything that isn't a hr, so his avg kills you, plus he strikes out a lot and k's are a stat you have. I would take Manny and valverde.

viewtopic.php?t=396020