I'd do it now and in a keeper, too. I know a lot of people are high on Markakis, but Reynolds is breaking out and doing it now. He's young, too, and has just as much of a chance at good future years. Besides, Reynolds plays a position that's harder to staff with quality. Good OFs are much easier to find.
If you had Pujols and Longoria at the corners, then maybe not, but that's not the case...
12 Team, H2H, Daily
C: J. Montero
1B: Morse, Hosmer
2B: Kipnis, Hill
OF: McCutchen, Harper, Reddick, Crisp
SP: Weaver, Cain, Gio Gonzalez, Gallardo, Cueto, Gee
RP: R. Soriano, Clippard, Frieri, Janssen
DL: Ellsbury, Gardner