Soria for Sizemore. Good or Bad Deal?

[D.Piston]

I put Soria on the trading block because I'm thinking of punting saves. I just got offered Sizemore for him. Grady Sizemore has been injured and I feel like he's going to be shut down early, so I'm thinking of countering. Getting Sizemore would be a bad deal for me right?

What would you do?
1) Trade Soria for Sizemore (and hope Sizemore stays active)
2) Trade Soria and (Arod or Votto) for Reynolds
3) Trade Soria, Zobrist and Uggla for Aaron Hill (Then pick up Beckham)
4) Stay put
5) Another deal idea?

10 Team/h2h/daily line up changes/1st place
My team:
Hitters:
C R Martin
1B Albert Pujols
2B Figgins
3B Álex Rodríguez
SS Tulo
OF Zobrist (2B, SS, OF elgible)
OF Rios
OF Quentin
Util/1B Joey Votto
BN Nelson Cruz
BN Uggla


Pitchers:
SP Javier Vázquez
SP Josh Johnson
SP A.J. Burnett
SP Chris Carpenter
SP Max Scherzer
SP J Pineiro
SP Edwin Jackson
SP R Nolasco
RP Joakim Soria
RP JP Howell

His Team:
C Mike Napoli
1B Mark Reynolds
2B Aaron Hill
3B Evan Longoria
SS Cristian Guzmán
OF Curtis Granderson
OF Carlos Lee
OF Raúl Ibañez
Util Ichiro Suzuki
BN Nick Swisher
BN Jhonny Peralta
BN Grady Sizemore
DL Geovany Soto

SP Félix Hernández
SP Jered Weaver
RP Brian Fuentes
RP Andrew Bailey
P Josh Beckett
P Rich Harden
P Rick Porcello - -
BN Jair Jurrjens
BN Carlos Zambrano

[joe112]

If you want Reynolds go for Soria for Reynolds straight up. #2 just stinks for you.

[D.Piston]

If you want Reynolds go for Soria for Reynolds straight up. #2 just stinks for you.

I doubt that's going to work. Reynolds has been a top 10 hitter almost all year long. I'm going to have to trade Soria and Votto (or more) to even get considered. He's playing Reynolds at 1st right now.

[MassYankee]

if its a keeper league, go get sizemore/

help me?
viewtopic.php?t=395939