Matt Gamel for Carlos Santana?

[motionman04]

I get Gamel, is this a good trade? Being that these two are very young, and in Santana's case, not even at major league level, I'm not sure what to do. I already have Buster Posey as a minor league prospect on my team. What do you all think?

[asquad89]

The guitarist?

[motionman04]

heh, the minor leaguer in the indians system

[bazzy_51]

seens how you already have Posey who i think will turn out to be a better big leaguer on a worse (at this time) roster then Santana... id pull the trigger for Gamel...

[motionman04]

I should also mention that I have v-mart at catcher as well who I plan to keep...

[Padres Fan]

as long as Gamel is eligible at 3B i would go for him, since you also have V-Mart and Posey
help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=396091

[briane]

Agreed, get Gamel if you can afford to give up Santana - I'd take VMart for 5 years before Santana for 15, ya just never know. I think Gamel is more likely to succeed at the Major League baseball.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=395889&p=3145615#p3145615