Mark Reynolds/Matt Holliday for Beckett, Abreu, Ibanez

[emorel1975]

Hi,

I am in a Keeper 5X5 league. We keep 7 and redraft the rest. Please help!!


Here is my roster:



C Mike Napoli, LAA C, DH
1B Justin Morneau, Min 1B, DH
2B Brandon Phillips, Cin 2B
3B Alex Rodriguez, NYY 3B
SS Stephen Drew, Ari SS S
2B/SS J.J. Hardy, Mil SS
1B/3B Mark Reynolds, Ari 1B, 3B
OF Carl Crawford, TB OF
OF Jermaine Dye, CWS OF
OF Adam Jones, Bal OF
OF Matt Holliday, StL OF
OF Josh Willingham, Was OF
UTIL Nick Swisher, NYY 1B, OF
Bench Torii Hunter*, LAA OF DL15
DL Ian Kinsler*, Tex 2B DL15
PITCHERS -
P John Lackey, LAA SP TB
SP Rick Porcello, Det SP PP
SP Jeremy Guthrie, Bal SP
SP Scott Feldman, Tex SP, RP
SP Aaron Cook, Col SP DTD
SP Andy Pettitte, NYY SP
RP Andrew Bailey, Oak SP, RP
RP Leo Nunez, Fla RP Hou 2-1
RP C.J. Wilson, Tex RP @Cle
Bench Ubaldo Jimenez, Col SP
Bench Ryan Dempster, ChC SP
Bench Scott Baker, Min SP
DL Tim Wakefield*, Bos SP


I give up SB, but upgrade my pitching. I am concerned about giving up the power of Reynolds (possible Career Year) and the 5 tools of Holliday.

I am currently in 1st in my division, but I do not think my pitching is good enough to take the title.

Let me know if you would do the deal.

[bazzy_51]

im guessing this is both Reynolds AND Holliday for Becket, Abreu, Ibanez... in which case i say hell no.. sell Reynolds at what everyone else is selling him at IMO it looks like this...

right now value:
Reynolds>Abreu and Ibanez
Holliday=Beckett

get better, or better yet younger OFers or a bigger value player to go with Beckett and Abreu then Ibanez (not saying hes bad, but you are giving up a TON of keeper youth to add one arm and 2 guys that you won't even keep in my eyes anyways) so you need a better keeper OF option to do it...

[emorel1975]

I was leaning towards declining it, but was intrigued by the upgrade. I drafted Reynolds only because he was great value, but never been a big fan. He is a drain on AVG and will not repeat his SB from this year. Thus, I was going to keep Beckett and another plaer on my roster, but I thought I may be giving up more then I was getting.

[REBEL5 AC]

Decline. Both players should be sold for higher and no way should you sell on Holliday right now. He is going to be great hitting behind Pujols.

Help????:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=395886

[DVauthrin]

i'd rather have reynolds and holliday.