Just offered two trades..help

[colt45s]

12 Team H2H 6 Keeper League

Trade #1

I give: Hanley, Haren, Ryan Doumit, and Leo Nunez

I get: Troy Tulowitzki, Josh Beckett, Derrek Lee, and Carlos Lee

Trade# 2

I give: Hanley, Chone Figgins, Roy Owsalt, Ryan Dempster, Adam Lind, and Aramis Ramirez

I get: David Wright, Ian Kinsler, Nelson Cruz, Yovani Gallardo, Javier Vázquez, and Franklin Gutiérrez

Which trade is better for Me??

Thank You

My team:

C Ryan Dounit
IB Pablo Sandoval
2B Chone Figgins
SS Hanley Ramirez
3B Aramis Ramirez
OF Andre Either
OF Alex Rios
OF Adam Lind
Util Matt Kemp
Util B.J. Upton
BN Russell Braynan
BN Gordon Beckham


SP Roy Oswalt
SP Dan Haren
SP Wandy Rodriguez
RP Leo Nunez
RP Francisco Cordero
SP Clayton Kershaw
P Tommy Hanson
P Ricky Nolasco
P J.A. Haap
P Jose Valverde
P Matt Lindstrom
P Ryan Dempster
DL Kevin Slowery

[taw856]

I like the second deal better. Not sure I'd even want to move Hanley in a keeper, but if you do, at least you're getting a lot in return for him in the second deal.

In a keeper...
Wright > ARam
Vazquez > Dempster
Cruz > Lind
Kinsler > Figgins
Oswalt might be better than Gallardo, but Gallardo's youth really helps here too.

So you're only losing in giving up Hanley, which was inherently part of moving him to begin with.

Mine: viewtopic.php?t=395664