How Do I pick 6 keepers out of these guys? HELP!! WHIR!

[swyck]

You've gotten some good advice already. The top three are easy, but you still have good choices after that.

Certain:
Morneau
Utley
Sizemore

Three of these:
A. Ramirez or Reynolds
Haren or Billingsley
Bay or Tulo

I'd go with Reynolds over ARam as its possible ARam has peaked and Reynolds have broken out big time. However the safe choice is ARam and you have to pick one of these as 3B isn't deep.

I like Haren over Billingsley, but I'd go with both. If you don't want to go with two SP then Bay or Tulo over Billingsley. Tulo has come into his own this year and SS is weak so that would be the best value choice.

M Ramirez and Jeter are too old to count on as keepers IMO. Doesn't mean they can't have great years next season, but I wouldn't count on it.