Beckham or Peralta....you choose??? WHIR!!!

[WhipperSnappers44]

Hey all.....simple question here:

Who would you rather have as a backup 3B for the rest of the year? (Beckham or Peralta)???

I currently have A.Huff at 3B and he has come back a little in the past couple games but not sure it will last. I noticed both Beckham and Peralta have been on fire the past "whatever" and am undecided on who wins here! Thanks for the help and I will help you 100%!

This is a Standard Yahoo 12 Team H2H league (10CAT) 5X5

Here is my team: I know I could put Derosa anywhere so why have a bench 3B but I will be dropping Willingham for them and since I have benched OF spots then I don't really need Willingham. Also, I tried grabbing some pitchers instead but the WW is all dried up!!! Thanks again!

My Team:

B.McCann, R.Howard, B.Roberts, A.Huff, D.Jeter, Ichiro, M.DeRosa, Adam Jones, J.Rivera (Bench: J.Lopez, R.Ludwick, J.Willingham)

A.Wainwright, R.Nolasco, M.Buerhle, AJ Burnett, J.Piniero, J.Marquis, B.Jenks, C.Qualls, D.Aardsma

NOTE: I have been playing DeRosa at 3B, Playing J.Rivera at OF and playing J.Lopez at Util since he has been on fire. I would play Ludwick but he has been cold! Also.....this league is almost impossible to trade with!! Thanks again and I WHIR!!!


WhipperSnappers44!!!

[The_Idiot]

I like Beckham over Peralta, but I like them both over Ludwick.

[DbacksRback]

I like beckham...help me out?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=395261

[BillyHallDisciple]

Go with Beckham.... Peralta is hot/cold and Cleveland's offense is kind of going south lately.

Help me if you can, deadline fast approaching for me
viewtopic.php?t=395260

[smoovethug]

Beckham.

[WhipperSnappers44]

Thanks all for the responses......all of yours have been answered as well.

I ended up dropping Willingham and picking up Beckham. Also, for the guy who said they would rather have Beckham and Peralta over Ludwick......must be smoking crack!!!....lol

Sure......Ludwick is on a cold streak but we all know he can hit and with the Cards lineup and power around him then he should be fine the rest of the way!

Thanks again!

WhipperSnapper44!!!

[Tenacious D-Store]

I'd take Ronny Cedeno before Peralta... OK no I wouldn't, but I'll take Beckham easily.