Rate these 4 Free Agent Players

[streaknasty09]

How would you rate the following players?

Gordon Beckham

Orlando Cabrera

Johnny Peralta

Garrett Jones

[jweb2244]

Thanks for help on mine...to answer your question, I was going to trade Valverde and Cordero plus a hitter. Do you think that is too much?

Also, you didn't ask for help in return but I will do anyway: I would rank your players in the order you listed them except move Jones up to #2. Thanks again.

[thejusman1]

Beckham

O-Cab

Jones (although this ride might be over)

Peralta

[streaknasty09]

Is it safe to drop Jones to pick up Beckham then?