Huge Keeper Trade. WHIR

[MotorCityKitties]

12 team league 7x7 Keeper (K's and OPS for batters & Holds and K/BB for pitchers)

C: Sandoval
1B: MCab
2B: Cano
3B: Arod
SS: Theriot
OF: VWells
OF: Cruz
OF: Abreu
OF: Damon
Util: Morneau
Util: Aybar
Util: Beckham
BN: Hardy
BN: Hart
DL: Beltran
DL: Beltre



SP: Jared Weaver
SP: Hamels
SP: Gallardo
RP: Street
RP: Qualls
RP: Hughes
P: Wandy Rod
P: Halladay
P: Rauch
P: Howell
BN: JJohnson
BN: Bucholz
BN: ESantana
BN: DeLaRosa
BN:Downs

I've been offered:

Pujols/Berkman/Hamilton

for

Arod/MCab

We keep 4 at the end of this season. I'm in second place and could conceivably win this league. What do you think?


Leave a link

[thejusman1]

I wouldn't do this trade if I were you. With Mcab and Arod, you'll be set at 1B and 3B for years to come. Berkman seems to have inconsistent seasons, last year being "on," and this year being "off." Hamilton is a high risk keeper because of his injuries, although we all know what he can do. I think you can actually keep Mcab, Arod, Halladay, and your choice of Sandoval/Hamels/Gallardo. That's still a very strong keeper list, more so I think than Pujols, Berkman, Hamilton, and Halladay.

Help on mine? viewtopic.php?t=395206

[Swagger]

Can you post what your keepers would be before and after the trade? Is this a roto league or one of those H2H category ones? Will Berkman slot into one of your Utility spots when he returns? Without knowing that info I'll do my best

I'm not a fan of Hamilton and I think Berkman is starting to get older (nursing an injury right now) and i would imagine you will not be using a keeper spot on him. Considering that you are giving up Arod and M Cab (both keepers, right?) for one keeper in Pujols.

I think this trade gives you a slight edge for this year but I think it's a bad trade for you in the long run. I would pass on this trade


Help

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=395207