Choo for which closer?

[ccsammy21]

I'm trying to get another closer for Choo. I'm looking at Valverde, Street, and Bailey. Which one would you take, and do you think it'd be a good trade or am I giving too much/too little? I feel like it's hard to gauge Choo's value for some reason....

[jman777772003]

choo's going 20/20 this year. i think he's more valuable than a closer in a vaccuum bc any closer can save 5 or 20 games the rest of the way, it's just hard to predict. but at this point in the year it's based on need and scarcity. so it's not that ridiculous of a trade. first, eliminate bailey, the a's just don't win enough games. i would take valverde over street and i don't think it's close, the astros usually have second half run in them and play a lot of close games due to lack of offense and decent pitching. street's been phenomenal but he's in colorado and has killed my fantasy teams in the past too many times for me to trust him (but this is a bitter ex-street owner talking)