bazzy_51 wrote:wow imagine that you bring a Jay or the Jay's team into this conversation.
#1. I knew you would like that. Why do you think I did it?
#2. Stop putting unnecessary apostrophes in "Jays." It is plural, and they aren't possessing anything.
did i say the Jay's are better without Halladay? NO. are Halladay and Manny even comparable players? NO. they play 2 totally different roles on their respected teams,
You missed the point. Both Manny and Halladay are elite players that contribute a lot to their teams. The fact that the teams did well in a small sample size of 2 weeks (Halladay's case) or 50 games (Manny's case) is meaningless. In the long term, the teams would be better off with them instead of guys like Brian Tallet and Juan Pierre.
seriously Halladay is struggling as of late but these 2 aren't even in the same category.
Yeah, Manny is a legitimate Hall of Famer, and Halladay isn't.
I mean...Manny Ramirez has a .965 OPS right now. That leads his team by a wide margin. I can't believe people are bashing this guy.