Aaron Hill + Max Scherzer for Matt Holliday

[activechamp2006]

I give Aaron Hill + Max Scherzer for Matt Holliday. Value based how does the deal look? The trade fits my team perfect, just not sure if i'm giving up too much. Especially with Reyes coming back soon, he can easily take over Hill's spot at UTIL.

This is a 16 team ROTO Keeper league. We keep 6 players.

c pablo sandoval
1b adrian gonzo
2b cano
ss jeter
3b miguel cabrera
of jason bay
of scott podsednik
of scott hairiston
util aaron hill
bench
jim thome
dexter fowler
DL jose reyes

sp cc sabathia
sp zach greinke
rp broxton
rp street
p aardsma
p matt cain
p chad billingsley
bench
max schzerer
chris tillman
ervin santana

[activechamp2006]

bump

[Eightan]

Not a bad trade, but I'd try and get a pitcher back if you feel like you're giving up too much. Oh and FYI, I wouldn't necessarily count Reyes as coming back so fast.... knowing the Mets, I'd like to see hime get consistent playing time before I count him as "back."

Help with mine... viewtopic.php?f=26&t=394669

[fantasysportsguy1210]

I think this is a good deal for you. It would be worth trying to get a down pitcher with some upside out of it. Scherzer has been pitching well, so you could probably score something.

[jaguiar88]

Not a bad deal , I do agree a SP would be good.

Please Help me
viewtopic.php?t=394672

[trevizzle]

as a holliday owner, i wouldn't do this trade. but this is amazing if you pull it off. even if you don't get a sp in return, consider this a major steal! you can easily make up scherzers numbers on the WW

[TheNephilim]

as a holliday owner, i wouldn't do this trade. but this is amazing if you pull it off. even if you don't get a sp in return, consider this a major steal! you can easily make up scherzers numbers on the WW

I may be going out on a limb here trevizzle, but I'm guessing you play in an 8 team league. In a 16 team league NO WAY you find scherzer caliber pitching on the wire. I think the deal is a good start at talks but you are giving up a little too much, shoot for a pitcher in return and see how he responds.