Abreu for Carpenter?

[beefcurtain]

Should I trade Abreu for Carpenter?

My OF - Abreu, BJ Upton, Kemp, Choo, Hawpe
MY SP - Billingsly, Cain, Pinero, E Santana, Parra, Braden, Smoltz, Randy Johnson.

Thanks. Leave a link and I'll return the help

[briane]

I would rather have Carpenter if he's healthy the rest of the year, Abreu if Carpenter is not. It depends on your categories that you need, but, in a vacuum, l'd rather have Abreu.

However, how many OF do you start? If 5, we'd need to know who is on the waiver wire.

IF 4, make the deal.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=394290

[beefcurtain]

We start three outfielders and a utilityman so I start four of them. Right now, Choo is on the bench.

[briane]

Based on that information, take the deal. I think I'd start Choo over Abreu anyhow.