No. Who would man 3b? Besides that, I think ARod and Braun are about equal. Hamilton and Sizemore are both big risks, but I don't see any reason for the Indians to not shut down Sizemore at some point. Plus, I know Lackey's had some rough starts, but he's pitched well lately, and at full strength I like him better than Zambrano.
I'd take the A-Rod side. Sizemore and Hamilton cancel each other out as first-round disappointments and A-Rod has shown to be healthy (and is producing like it now), which gives that side the edge. I'd rather have Lackey over Zambrano by a good bit as well.