HELP!! A rod, j.Ham, n Lackey for Braun, Sizemore, and Big Z

[augustbick]

Would you make this trade?

I would trade A rod, Hamilton, and Lackey for Braun, Sizemore, and Big Z.

Here is my full Roster..This Is a keeper league. 4 players.

Molina, Varitek, Pujols, Pedroia, A-Rod, Hanley, H. Kendrick, Teixeira, M.Bradley, Hamilton,
Cameron, Pence, G. Jones, D. Lee

M. Buehrle, J. Contreras, J. De La Rosa, J. Lackey, M. Rivera, C.C. Sabathia, F. Carmona, J. Moyer, R. Porcello, J.O. Sanchez, T. Hudson, J. Peavy, J. Schmidt, K. Hart, J. Smoltz, C. Buchholz

[jackie hayes]

No. Who would man 3b? Besides that, I think ARod and Braun are about equal. Hamilton and Sizemore are both big risks, but I don't see any reason for the Indians to not shut down Sizemore at some point. Plus, I know Lackey's had some rough starts, but he's pitched well lately, and at full strength I like him better than Zambrano.

[ayebatter]

Would you make this trade?

No I wouldn't, but I'd add 4 more teams to the league for the 2010 season.

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd take the A-Rod side. Sizemore and Hamilton cancel each other out as first-round disappointments and A-Rod has shown to be healthy (and is producing like it now), which gives that side the edge. I'd rather have Lackey over Zambrano by a good bit as well.