Is Choo for Young a good counter offer WHIR?

[jealousblues]

OK, I had someone offer me Jason Bay, Michael Young, and James Shields for David Wright and Choo

How does a counter of Choo for Young sound?

(im also offering up Todd Helton for Mark DeRosa in a seperate deal with another team)

10 team head to head

R
HR
RBI
SB
PO
A
OPS


C Jorge Posada(NYY - C)
1B Justin Morneau(Min - 1B)
2B Chase Utley(Phi - 2B)
3B David Wright(NYM - 3B)
SS Stephen Drew(Ari - SS)
CI Aramis Ramírez(ChC - 3B)
MI Dustin Pedroia(Bos - 2B)
OF Andrew McCutchen(Pit - OF)
OF Ryan Braun(Mil - OF)
OF Ryan Ludwick(StL - OF)
Util Todd Helton(Col - 1B)
BN Shin-Soo Choo(Cle - OF)
BN Colby Rasmus(StL - OF)
DL Carlos Beltrán(NYM - OF) DL
DL Vladimir Guerrero(LAA - OF) DL


W
SV
K
TB
ERA
WHIP
SP Chris Carpenter(StL - SP)
SP Ricky Nolasco(Fla - SP)
RP Mariano Rivera(NYY - RP)
RP Ryan Franklin(StL - RP)
P David Aardsma (Sea - RP)
P Kerry Wood(Cle - RP)
P Scott Downs(Tor - RP)
BN John Lackey(LAA - SP)
BN Edwin Jackson(Det - SP)
BN Scott Kazmir(TB - SP)

[Bobby B 11]

for a 10 team league your pitching is very weak. id take this deal if he gives you a better pitcher than shields.

[jealousblues]

Everyones pitching is a little weak, one guy drafted this:

now maybe I trade with him

Josh Beckett
Tim Lincecum
Jonathan Papelbon
J.P. Howell
Andrew Bailey
Joakim Soria
Ramon Troncoso
Yovani Gallardo
Roy Halladay
Cole Hamels
Johan Santana
Zack Greinke



id also consider trading for pitching when Vlad and/or Beltran come back

[misterf]

That's not a totally unreasonable counter offer, but I highly doubt that the other manager will go for it. Even though I'm not totally buying into choo, their overall rankings are probably in the same ballpark. However, the mater of position scarcity makes Young much more valuable. There are a lot of outfielders that can give you Choo-like numbers in the OF, but there aren't many 3B's or SS's of Young'd caliber. I highly doubt the other guy will give up Young unless he gets a 3B or SS in return.


By the way, why is McCuthen starting over Choo?


Pleace help with mine:

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=394209

[jealousblues]

I think choo had an offday or I had been slow or soemthing, or i didnt like a match up so I took him out for a day
hes been a starting OFer on my team for a long time

[jealousblues]

thanks for the help so far.

please leave links