Rate these catchers please WHIR

[flyfishwa]

I have AJ Pierzynski, and he seems to be losing steam. Kurt Suzuki and Yadier Molina are free agents. Please rate these three catchers...


CBS 14 team H2H League
5x5 Scoring
1 Reserve, and 1 DL slot
Roster:
C: A.J. Pierzynski
1B: Kevin Youkilis
2B: Ian Kinsler
3B: Chipper Jones
SS: Hanley Ramirez
MI: Adam Kennedy
CI: Marcus Scutaro
OF1: Matt Kemp
OF2: Jermaine Dye
OF3: Jayson Werth
OF4: Andre Ethier
OF5: Marlon Byrd
U: Andy LaRoche
DL1: Scott Hairston

SP1: Dan Haren
SP2: James Shields
SP3: Javier Vazquez
RP1: Brian Fuentes
SP4: ?
RP2: Heath Bell
RP3: Kevin Gregg
SP5: Wandy Rodriguez
SP6: Hiroki Kuroda
SP7: Zach Duke
DL1: Chris R. Young

[Bobby B 11]

yadier, aj, suzuki

[misterf]

I would give Yadier a very slight edge, followed by AJ and then Suzuki.....but honestly I think all three are roughly equal in overall value.

I would consider just going with whoever is the hot hand at the time. As long as there aren't any penalties or restrictions for transactions in your league, I wouldn;t hesitate to swap them out as each one gets hot or cold (or has a favorable/tough matchup for any given week).

If you want to stick with one catcher...I would actually look at their respective schedules in the playoff weeks to see who is facing week teams and/or is playing in hitters parks to help make the decision.

Please help with mine:

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=394209