Carlos Lee or Aramis Ramirez ??? (WHIR)

[jweb2244]

I am trading pitching for hitting, and he has given me my choice of Carlos Lee or Aramis Ramirez. I would normally think Lee, but he doesn't seem to be the same this year (although a GS today) and Aramis is a 3B, which is harder to find.

Which one should I take? 5x5 Standard Roto.

Thanks!

[raek]

Completely depends on your team. Who are you replacing at those spots?

[jweb2244]

To Raek: whichever one I get goes into Utility, so no one of value is being replaced either way (the only reason I mentioned Aramis value as a 3B is to use him as trade bait since already have Longoria).

[raek]

Hmm.. in that case I'd say its very close. Im leaning towards Lee, but if you think you really can flip ARam because he's 3B, then I'd go that route.

[DVauthrin]

i'd rather have lee. aramis is still fighting his shoulder.