sizemore for ichiro

[bob-oh]

I'm in a 15 player keeper league and I' pretty much stuck in 6th. I have Ichiro. Seein how sizemore needs surgery and ichiro is gettin up there in age. Would you trade sizemore for ichiro? I have a young team and lookin to build a team to compete in another year or two.

[raek]

I wouldnt, I dont see Ichiro slowing down, regardless of age. Sizemore just has too many question marks for me.

Help with mine please:

viewtopic.php?t=393883

[DVauthrin]

i'd take grady hands down, especially if you are stuck in mediocrity this year. ichiro is very good, but if healthy sizemore is on a different level.

[raek]

I guess that "if healthy" is what sticks me.

[DVauthrin]

I guess that "if healthy" is what sticks me.

it's understandable. my viewpoint is this:

for this year, I'd take ichiro. for next year, i'll take sizemore easily over ichiro. considering he said his team is in 6th place and it's a keeper league, i'd pull the trigger.

[raek]

Yeah. plus the "trying to build a team for the future" part, I'd probably go ahead and do it.

[bob-oh]

Thanks guys. That is kinda how I felt. I just didn't know if anyone had any "inside" info on his shoulder i.e. how long he'd be out if surgery is done. Thanks though