Thanks for the reply!.....Ummmmmm.......but are you serious here?
I wouldn't give up Halladay for any of those guys.....well, if your deep in at SP and you need the position fill then I would go with Berkman and then Votto (in that order) but I definately would not trade for Loney who is the worse one of the bunch.....heck, I wouldn't take Loney for free!
This question must be a joke so I'll move on but if you must trade then I would trade for Berkman only and/or Votto plus Loney but that's it my friend!
I would like to see your SP's though to see what warrants trading Halladay? Also, I would sit Weiters, move VicMart to C and then either do the trade for Berkman or Votto+ and put them at 1B or don't do the trade and at least put G.Jones at 1B.