C.Pena for J.Johnson

[Ticky20]

I have been offered Pena for Josh Johnson. If i did this trade i would have to drop one of my batters as we have no bench in my league. Heres my roster let me know what you think i should do. WHIR

C. Weiters
1B. Votto
2B. Utley
3B. Longo
SS. Hanley
OF. Grady
OF. Dunn
OF. Pence
Util. M.Reynolds
Util. A.Hill
Util. A.Lind
Util. Rollins
Util. Big Papi
DL. Beltran

SP. Lincecum
SP. Verlander
SP. Weaver
SP. J.Johnson
SP. Kershaw
RP.Papelbon
RP. H.Street
DL. Webb

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you

[yankeetiger]

I wouldn't take it.

Votto is easily good enough at first for you, and not worth flipping Johnson for in that situation IMO.

[ltrocq]

i wouldn't do it. josh johnson has been GREAT, and you're already pretty set at util with reynolds.

[The Real Quiz]

I would do it ... if Pena fit nicely into your benchless team. There's just no good/advantageous way to fit in Pena. Plus, Johnson is really showing his best stuff this year. Stick with Johnson.



viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393966

[DVauthrin]

As a fellow johnson owner, I would want much more than pena for JJ.