being a philies fan I would imediatly say utley but....getting roberts and johnson...hmmm id accept that deal...of course it would also depend on what what I needed but i would consider parting ways with utley in this trade so i would say who ever is getting roberts and johnson would get a slight advantage in the deal
Very even, but without knowing anything else about league settings and your team, I'm taking Utley.
We need to know how big the league is, what the settings are, and who you're going to drop to answer this question fairly, though. If you can stand to lose the pitching and need power, then it's a great deal.
I made the original post when I was pretty tired and forgot to include some info. This is a deal I am thinking about proposing, it's a 6x6 league(standard plus 2B and IP). This is the first year of a brand new keeper league and my roster is as follows:
C-Pierzynski 1B-Prince Fielder 2B-Brian Robers 3B-Aramis Ramirez SS-Hanley Ramirez OF-Johnny Damon, Ryan Ludwick, Jason Kubel Util-Miguel Cabrera BN-Cody Ross BN-Russell Branyan DL-Torii Hunter
SP-Feix Hernandez SP-Josh Johnson SP-Randy Wells SP-Randy Wolf SP-Ricky Nolasco SP-Doug Davis SP-John Smoltz SP-Jose Contreras DL-Tim Hudson
In this league, if you make the playoffs you keep 4 players, if you don't you get to keep 5. Unless something drastic happens, I will be in the playoffs. I'm considering offering it because this would give me my 4th definite keeper(Cabrera, Hanley, Prince, Utley). As of right now, I'm on the fence about who the 4th would be. As of right now, Jarrod Washburn, Gavin Floyd, and Joe Blanton are all free agents so I would pick up one of them with my extra spot essentially making the deal Roberts/Johnson for Utley/Washburn.