Would You Accept This Trade?

[rasto21585]

Basically I was offered Miguel Cabrera and Bobby Abreu for Justin Morneau and Ryan Ludwick. Would you do this deal?

20 team dynasty league

My Roster
C-Russell Martin
1B-justin morneau
2B-luis valbuena
3B-pablo sandoval
SS-ryan theriot
IF-chase headley
LF-carlos lee
CF-ryan ludiwck
RF-alex rios
OF-colby rasmus
Util- kosuko fukodome
BN dayan viciendo alexi caslla willie harris
DL Xavier Nady aki iwamura

SP-micah owings
SP-Jon Lester
SP-wandy rodriguez
SP-John Danks
RP-George Sherrill
RP-Rafael Soriano
RP-Jeremy Accardo
RP-Mike Adams
P-Jair Jurrjens
P-Hiroki Kuroda
P-Jeremy Guthrie
BN-carlos carrasco gio gonzalez scott elbert dustin nippert


His Roster

c ryan doumit
1b miguel cabrera
2b chris coghlan
3b alex rodriguez
ss jerry hairston jr
if brandon wood
lf scott podsednik
cf mike cameron
rf bobby abreu
of delmon young
util franklin gutierrez
bn willy aybar
bn matt joyce
dl carlos delgado

sp ja happ
sp john lannon
sp brett cecil
sp homer bailey
rp joe nathan
rp jason motte
rp carlos villanueva
rp jose valverde
p sean marshall
p jose mijares
p scott downs
bn david hernandez
bn andy petite
bn ryan perry
bn anthony swarzak
dl josh outman

[plapre3]

Well, I'd need to know a little more, like are you in close contention and what the stat cats are, but in general I like the deal. I'd take Miggy over Morneau in the long run and Abreu is looking more and more like a guy who can be productive into his 40s. I'm not a big Ludwick fan given his inconsistencies this year, so take this with a grain of salt if you feel otherwise.

Please return the favor:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393851

[MaudDib]

I think it is a push. Miggy and Morneau are very similar players and I think a case could be made for either one. Ludwick and Abreu are also both 3rd/4th OF and again a case could be made for either one. This is one of those trades that I don't see making a big difference for your team so pick which player you personally like more.

[GOD]

Get Cabby, He should be a better keeper in the long haul.

[yearbend]

miguel cabrera is the best player in this trade, i would keep him.

[Johnny Tuttle]

It is close, but I take the younger slugger who could play 3B for you this year in a pinch.

viewtopic.php?t=393907