should i do this trade? WHIR

[notandrew]

I was offered adam jones, giovany soto, johan santana, mark buehrle & bobby jenks for raul ibanez, ryan doumit, felix hernandez, carlos zambrano & fernando rodney. Do u think i should do it?

C- Russell Martin, Ryan Doumit
1B- Carlos Pena, Paul Konerko
2B- Aaron Hill
3B- Chone Figgins
SS- Hanley Ramirez, Miguel Tejada
OF- Raul Ibanez, Torii Hunter(DL) Andre Ethier, Carlos Lee, Matt Holliday

SP- Felix Hernandez, Yovani Gallardo, Carlos Zambrano, Zach Duke, Hiroki Kuroda, David Price & Edison Volquez(DL)
RP- Jonathon Broxton, Brian Fuentes, Fernando Rodney & Hideki Okajima(for holds)

[attaraxia]

i would do it, but see if you can swap zambrano for duke in that trade.

what do you think?
viewtopic.php?t=393754

[DVauthrin]

I like the deal for you. johan is still higher than felix in my book, and I like jones/jenks more than ibanez and rodney the rest of the way.

[MaudDib]

That is a big trade. I am never fan of trades with more than four guys. It is hard to judge when there are that many players involved plus more risk involved. Soto is already hurt. Personally I would either keep what you have or pair down the trade. good luck