My Soriano+Doumit+Lackey for Vmart+Quent+Vlad+G Floyd

[adkhkr]

What do you think? I was going to offer this...

Here is my team in a 5x5, H2H, 12 team, Mixed, Non-Keeper League:

My Team
C Ryan Duomit
1B Jorge Cantu
2B Jose Lopez
3B Aramis Ramirez
SS Hanley Ramírez
OF Alfonso Soriano
OF Matt Kemp
OF Manny Ramirez
Util Colby Rasmus


SP Clayton Kershaw
SP Dan Haren
SP Josh Johnson
RP Francisco Cordero
RP Mike MacDougal
P Josh Beckett
BN John Lackey
BN Randy Wells
BN Francisco Liriano
BN Mike Hampton
DL Chien-Ming Wang
DL Scott Richmond

[Salty-Dog]

why would you want two injured guys?

[adkhkr]

I guess trying to win on the upside of the trade should Vlad and Quentin when they come back. I am tired of having Alfonso, its too damn frustrating.

[2muchchalk]

i would take a chance and do that deal. If one of them remains healthy (including service time from the other guy), u got yourself a heck of a deal. it is not like alfonso is ripping it up he is hitting .220.

please help
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393724

[Salty-Dog]

I don't think Quentin is coming back, or if he does plantar faciatis is brutal and will impair his ability - I guess I would stick it out and hope Soriano improves - over hoping two injury prone players come back at some point

just my opinion

[Hit Factory]

I'm not too high on Soriano and I like the combo of Vlad/Quentin much better.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393753

[DVauthrin]

you are asking for way too much. soriano is healthy, but he's been terrible this year.

[adkhkr]

I'm leaning on not doing it...who knows whats going to happen Quentin and Vlad is out for a month. You really think its a good trade?

[Daulton]

Quentin just started a rehab assignment today...it's worth offering to see if he'll still accept.

[adkhkr]

This is whats on the table now...

Vmart, Quentin, vlad, Gavin Floyd for My Soriano, doumit, lackey

What do you guys think?