Who wins in this trade

[T Long]

Carlos Beltran, Bobby Abreu and Chipper Jones

for

Miguel Cabrera, Alex Rios and Denard Span

[rib217]

Really tough to tell without knowing keeper or not, etc.

If Beltran wasnt on the DL, I would go with the Beltran side for sure. Beltran on the DL makes it maybe lean slightly toward Miggy's side but even then the Beltran side looks pretty good to me.


mine: viewtopic.php?t=393580

[plapre3]

Well, there's a lot else that I'd need to know.... Is this a keeper league? Is one team going for it and another player for next year? Stat Cats?

I'd say the Miggy side wins, especially since Beltran is injured, but it's hard to say.

Anyway, I could use some help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393583

[Tireur]

Miggy side for sure. I doubt Beltran is back this year, and if he does come back he's gonna suck for a few weeks off the DL I think.

Miggy side gets the best player, and I think Rios is better than Abreu. Chipper is solid, but injury prone. Span is alright.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=393579

[T Long]

thanks guys, and forgot to say nonkeeper