Sandoval Ibanez trade....yes or no? WHIR

[AVladRod]

Hey there, thanks for looking. 10 team keeper league...in first place. Sandoval wouldn't be eligible for C next year and im pretty blocked at both of those posittions (WE KEEP 10) so im considering this deal.

I get: Ibanez and Harden
I give up: Nolasco and Sandoval

what should i do? i have doumit so i could fill up the catxher slot, also napoli available on the wire as well. will answer any one else...thanks


C Sandoval
1B Pena
2B Roberts
3B Arod
SS Rollins
OF Soriano
OF Beltran (DL)
OF Crawford
UTIL Ortiz
UTIL Dye
Bench: Bruce(DL), Blalock, Doumit, Atkins

SP Halladay
SP Billingsley
SP E. Santana
SP Nolasco
SP Oswalt
Other P's: Smoltz, Blackburn, Slowey(DL), Peavy, (DL)

thanks again

[AVladRod]

anyone with a little advice?

[twistedude]

I don't like it - mostly because Sandoval/Nolasco have superior keeper value than Ibanez/Harden. Sandoval is gonna be a stud, only 22 years old now and he's raking. Ibanez won't come close to his first half production for the rest of the season. And I'm very high on Nolasco for the remainder of the season, he's gonna be an ace.

[HldOnMgnolia]

I agree with the above. It looks like Nolasco could end up being one of your 10 keepers at season's end and Ibanez is almost in the same boat as Dye in that regard. Harden hasn't been as lights out this year as he usually is and he only gives you ~140 innings anyway.

Keep what you have.

[notandrew]

i think you are getting the worst of this because u can get much more for sandoval

[AVladRod]

does the fact that i have doumit do anything for the deal?

[Richie Rich]

Not a fan of this b/c Nolasco is pitching well, and I really don't like Harden. Sandoval is hitting very well and is a solid player even not at the C spot...

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393575&p=3129782#p3129782

[AVladRod]

bump

[plapre3]

I definitely like the idea of dealing Sandoval, but not like this. I'd much rather have Nolasco over Harden both for the remainder of this season and as a keeper. Ibanez is a good target, but you could likely get a slightly lesser player (Choo, Ethier?) straight up for Sandoval and be much better off.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=393583